Sermon for Ash Wednesday, 18 February 2015

Reflection for Ash Wednesday
18 February 2015
Lutheran Church of the Redeemer, Jerusalem

The Rev. Carrie B. Smith


Grace and peace to you from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.

Photo by Danae Hudson
It’s an odd ritual, and yet we do it every Ash Wednesday: we hear these words from Jesus about not showing our piety before others, and then we immediately have black crosses smudged on our foreheads and go on to work, to the bus, or to the grocery store. While we may not receive rewards for doing this, we most certainly receive strange looks.

But on this day, in this particular week, when we wear the mark of Christ on our heads, we remember how twenty-one Christians recently lost their heads for no other reason than that they were baptized members of the Body of Christ.


For this reason, the simple liturgical act of being marked with the cross today takes on a deeper significance. Most of us in this room have never needed to keep our faith a secret, and have never truly experienced religious persecution. But whether or not we, in our contexts, are in mortal danger for wearing the cross of Christ on our bodies, our hearts are in solidarity today with those twenty-one men who lost their lives for the same cross. God grant them rest eternal, and may the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, guard the hearts and minds of their loved ones in Christ Jesus. Amen.

Of course, it now must be clearly stated that to think of the cross we are about to receive as some kind of flag of solidarity or symbol of triumph would be entirely missing the point of the day and of the church season to come. “Beware of practicing your piety before others in order to be seen by them; for then you have no reward from your Father in heaven” says Jesus. The ashes we wear on Ash Wednesday are not signs that we are especially good or holy. They don’t show solidarity with the persecuted or resistance to the rise of secularism or prove any political point whatsoever. These ashes are ashes, nothing more, and when we wear them, we are “outed” not as people of extraordinary faith, but as people of completely ordinary mortality. We are dust, and to dust we shall return.

The funny thing is, facing this simple truth about ourselves can feel as frightening as any external terror or threat.

I heard a radio news story the other day about a proposal in the United States to sell food that has gone past its expiration date (or food that simply doesn’t appear fresh anymore) to the underprivileged. This was conceived as a way of dealing with both the immense amount of waste in American culture, and the increasing problem of malnutrition among the poor and the working poor. The innovator of this new program said, in short: “The idea is that if we make this expired and bruised produce cheaper than fast food, poor people will buy it, we won’t have to throw it out, and everybody wins.”

Now, there is much I’d like to say about this news story. In fact, there’s far too much to say about this proposed “solution” to poverty and what it reveals about how we view the value of other human beings, but today, it’s the foundation of this story that has my attention. This is a story about an American culture problem, but deep down it also reveals a universal human nature problem.

What this story illustrates is our human aversion to brokenness and our fear of mortality.

We are so afraid of imperfection, we won’t even eat a bruised banana.

We are so afraid of decay, scientists have created a bio-engineered apple which will not turn brown after being cut.

We are so afraid of things that are not fresh, and we so value the imperishable, that we will refuse to eat food that has passed its official, corporately stamped, arbitrarily chosen expiration date—but will happily pass it on to others, whose mortality is apparently less concerning.

And so it is quite the scandal that on Ash Wednesday Christians wear our imperfections, our bruises, our faults, our sins, and our mortality on our very bodies. 

This is the day we get real with ourselves. On this one day a year, we wear our expiration dates on our foreheads.

Someone has even said Ash Wednesday is the day all Christians celebrate their funerals in advance.

Isn’t that a lovely thought! 

This could all seem very depressing indeed, if it weren’t for the presence of God’s imperishable grace, love and mercy amidst the dust, decay, and death of this perishable world. American Catholic monk and writer Thomas Merton even makes the case that Ash Wednesday isn’t a sorrowful day at all, but rather a joyful one. A feast, in fact! He said Ash Wednesday is a joyous feast because it is on this day that we let go of the false promises of the world, the false hopes of immortality, the false trust in these frail bodies, the false sense that perfection and achievement and beauty are what will make our lives worthwhile, and instead rest completely and totally on the goodness and love of God which we have seen in Christ Jesus and the cross.

Thomas Merton writes:

“In laying upon us the light cross of ashes, the Church desires to take off our shoulders all other heavy burdens—the crushing load of worry and guilt, the dead weight of our own self-love. We should not take upon ourselves a “burden” of penance and stagger into Lent as if we were Atlas, carrying the whole world on his shoulders. . . Penance is conceived by the Church less as a burden than as a liberation. It is only a burden to those who take it up unwillingly. Love makes it light and happy. And that is another reason why Ash Wednesday is filled with the lightness of love.”

I must admit, it’s a new concept for me to think of Ash Wednesday and the season of Lent as being “light and happy”. We’re accustomed to thinking of this as a “heavy” time, a time of solemnity and restriction: No Alleluias during the liturgy. No desserts at Wednesday night church fellowship. No meat on Fridays, depending on your tradition. No coffee, no chocolate, no Facebook…depending on your personal piety.

But seen in this new light, Lent can be a journey to freedom rather than a forty day sentence to serve. As Merton points out, this can be forty days of shedding our reliance on our own abilities, and forty days of increasing our need for God’s grace and love. This can be forty days of liberation from dysfunction, and forty days of getting into right relationship with God, with our neighbors, with our own bodies.

Today can begin forty days of giving thanks that we are dust, but that dust is not all there is. After all, it was dust, imbued with the breath of God, which brought you, and everyone you know and love, into being. This same dust was made holy when Jesus, the Son of God, walked with us, experiencing all our joys and sorrows. It was from the dust and dirt of the tomb that Jesus was raised, conquering death once and for all. We are dust, and to dust we shall return. But because God so loved the world—dust and all—this is not a message of gloom and doom, but rather Good News of light, love, and liberation.

We are dust. God is love. Thanks be to God.



Comments